Civil war meets COVID-19: Cameroon as a case study in deterioration and chaos

August 14th, 2020
Just as it is our moral duty to join the global collaborative efforts to ...

Cameroon: Gruesome Crimes, Impunity And A Disturbing Trend

August 14th, 2020
The catalogue of crimes targeting civilians in the Southern Cameroons and ...

Cameroon: Outrage as Suspected Amba Fighters “Slaughter” Woman in Muyuka

August 12th, 2020
The gruesome killing of lady, 35-year-old mother of four has caused great ...

International Youth Day 2020: Engaging Cameroonian Youth in Policy Making to Promote Health.

August 10th, 2020
Young people in Cameroon have   been catalysing important conversations on ...

Keeping them Honest: Your Country Needs You Mark Bareta is asking whose side are you on?

November 14th, 2017
Keeping them Honest: Your Country Needs You Mark Bareta is asking whose side ...

Cameroun soldiers shot local boat driver

November 14th, 2017
Soldiers loyal to LR's dictator, Mr. Biya just shot at a boat driver in ...

MP's of Cameroon's main opposition party, SDF boycott parliamentary session

November 14th, 2017
Members of Cameroon's parliament from the main opposition partyoon, The Social ...

Southern Cameroons : PGSST Bafut on fire

November 14th, 2017
Fresh reports reaching Cameroon Concord say Presbyterian School of Science and ...

Saint Pius college Ekondo Titi, ravaged by fire

November 14th, 2017
Another private institution has been burnt by unknown individuals. The fire ...

2018 world cup: Indomitable Lions miss 8.4 billion FCFA after dropping out

November 14th, 2017
The indomitable Lions will not benefit from the sum of 8.4 billion Fcfa, which ...

Five military personnel of La Republique du CameroUn found dead

November 13th, 2017
Reports reaching Cameroon Concord say some five military personnel of La ...

Anglophone crisis: One dead in Muyuka

November 13th, 2017
At least one civilian has reportedly died in Muyuka in the South West region  ...

Football-Russia 2018: All you need to know about 28 teams that have already qualified

November 13th, 2017
The final round of World Cup qualifying is taking place, and 27 countries are ...

Anglophone crisis: Politician Adamou Ndam Njoya calls for review of 1991 Tripartite Conference

November 13th, 2017
The chairman of Cameroon Democratic Union has called for a political debate to ...

Anglophone crisis : Nocturnal gunfire leaves Bamenda in fear

November 13th, 2017
After imposing a curfew in  some parts of the North West region, especially in ...

Road connecting Nigeria to Cameroon in Cross River cut off, road users stranded

November 12th, 2017
The only road that connects Nigeria to Cameroon through Cross River State is in ...
×

Warning

JUser: :_load: Unable to load user with ID: 770

Health / Medical

Uganda Confirms 1 Death
KAMPALA — Uganda’s ministry of health confirmed Thursday that one person has died of Marburg hemorrhagic fever, a close relative of the Ebola virus.
20 Oct 2017
Urgent Action Under Way
An emergency vaccination campaign is getting under way in northeastern Nigeria to prevent a deadly cholera outbreak from spreading to other
19 Sep 2017
Cholera Outbreak
ONDON —  At least 1.4 million people uprooted by Boko Haram's insurgency in northeast Nigeria are living in 'cholera hotspots,' prey to an
08 Sep 2017
Controversial
The Minister of Public Health has appointed Jean II  Dissongo Regional Delegate of Public Health for Littoral, barely 19 months after his sacking.The
06 Sep 2017
Scientific breakthrough
A landmark drug study has opened up a potent way to lower the risk of heart attacks — beyond the now standard advice of reducing cholesterol —
28 Aug 2017
Heart Attack vs. Cardiac
What Is It?Cardiac arrest, sometimes called sudden cardiac arrest, means that your heart suddenly stops beating. This cuts off blood flow to the
24 Aug 2017

Evolution of Defence Systems in International Tribunals

By Chief Charles A. Taku

The preamble of the United Nations Charter, establishes conditions under which“justice and respect for the obligations arising from treaties and other sources of international law” can be maintained for “promoting social progress and better standards of life in larger freedom”.To underscore this commitment, Article 1 of the United Nations Charter specifies that collective peaceful measures required for the prevention and removal of threats to peace; the maintenance of international peace and security should conformto “the principles of justice and international law”. The “right to defense and legal assistance of choice” before “competent, independent and impartial tribunals established by law” constitutes one of the minimum guarantees afforded by the UN System, multilateral and bilateral treaties for the attainment of this goal. The trials that were organized after WW II were a major test of the collective resolve of the civilized world to attain this goal. Was this goal attained? If it did, why then is the recognition of the defense as an independent organ of international tribunals and courts still elusive almost some 75 years after this stated goal? The main function of criminal trials is to establish the guilt or innocence of accused through fair processes.  According to Professor JeniaIontcheva Turner, even the Nuremberg proceedings were expected to comply with notions of fairness and individual criminal responsibility. However, the Tribunals establish for that purpose like all other international criminal tribunals and this includesICTR whose legacy we are celebrating, had a mandate to establishedenduring standards for future trials.

It was in so doing that these tribunals could validly be said to present clear alternatives to international criminality, impunity and the scourge of war that threatened and still threatens humanity; jeopardizing our common destiny. To fulfill this purpose, the tribunals had legitimately to be seen as platforms of fairness, independence and equality from which to assert and proclaim the primacy of the rule of law over impunity and international criminality.  Fairness, independence and equality in this context required institutional independence of Judges, the Registry, the Prosecutor and the Defense. The intendment of article 1 of the UN Charter is discernablein article 14 of the Intentional Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966) which laid down the minimum standards for the guarantees of fair trials. The Security Council through itsremarkable recognition of the defense as an independent organ of the Lebanon Tribunal led by example in the fulfillment of this pledge and indisputably set the standard for all international courts and tribunals to follow. The statutes of theICTR, art 20, ICTY art 21, SCSL art 17, ICC art 67, East Timor, Regulation 2000/30 as amended, recognize the minimum fair trial guarantees afforded accused persons  under  article 14 of the ICCPR  but not the institutional independenceof the defense for the effective enforcement of these rights.This omission does not accord withthethe principles of justice and international law” enshrined in article 1 and the preamble ofthe UN Charter and the minimum fair trial guarantees contained in their respective statutes.

The evolution of the Defense cannot be separated out from the implementation of all the fair trial guarantees to an Accused, under Articles 20 (ICTR), 21 (ICTY), 17 (SCSL) 67 ICC statutes.It is desirable that fora criminal trial process to be fair and seen to be fair; established values that serve the interest of humanity must be promoted and protected. To attain this goal, the principal participants in the trial process, and the defense is one, must be accorded equal recognition, independence and equal institutional status within which to function. The evolution of the defense from Nuremberg to the Special Court for Lebanon has been remarkable in some respects.  Robert Gellately in his introduction to “The Nuremberg Interviews” by Leone Goldensohn states that the main proceedings comprising “prosecution and defense presentations, lasted over nine months” and that there were four judges, and four prosecutors (with alternates), each with a team of his own, all drawn from the victorious powers-the United States, Great Britain, and the Soviet Union, along with France. The defense at Nuremberg was only recognized for its participation and presentations during the trials and not for its institutional independence, relevance and the resources provided for an effective defense. Despite the paucity of resources and the lack of recognition as an independent organ of the tribunal, the defense still managed to secure three significant acquittals; an impressive result in such circumstances.

Administrative and supervisory role of the Registrar

Lacking institutional recognition, the administration of the defense in international criminal tribunals and courts is placed under the authority of the Registrars of the respective courts. In defining the functions of the Registrar, the statutes of these courts are silent on the administration of the defense. 

The Rules of Procedure and Evidence of international criminal tribunals and courts provide for the assignment of counsel, appointment of counsel,misconduct of counsel, appointment of duty counsel, while their specific directives regulate the activities of counsel.

Roaster of competent counsel

The Registrars of different courts and tribunals have been fairly successful in attracting pools of very competent and professional lawyers from the major legal traditions of the world.

Inadequate resources

One of the most significant factors inhibiting the independence and effectiveness of the defense is the lack of resources.   Despite the fair trial guarantees contained in the statutes of many international courts and tribunals, the provision of adequate resources to the defense was and remains a significant challenge.  The Appeals Chamber of the ICTY decided in the case of Prosecutor V. Tadic that an accused person is entitled to an equality of arms in the preparation and presentation of his defense, which at minimum means that an accused have adequate time and facilities for his defense. However the Appeals Chamber held that this right is circumscribed by the availability of resources by the international tribunal.

In any case, whatever one's position; whether the defense is inside or outside the judicial institution, there must be equality of resources. Equality of arms must mean the same monies to the Defense as to the Prosecution, same number of positions and the same privileges and possibilities to contribute meaningfully to the judicial processes intended to deliver free and fair justice to accused, victims and the world at large.

Security of counsel

Despite the protections and functional immunity provided lawyers in the performance of their duties provided by The Basic Principles on the Role of Lawyersadopted by the Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and Treatment of Offenders, Havana, Cuba, 27 August to 7 September, 1990”defense counsel at some international tribunals and courts were subjected to egregious violations, arrests and humiliating treatment. To their credit, the ICTR and the Special court for Sierra Leone will go down in history for affording the greatest protection possible to defense counsel in the fulfillment of their mandates. The arrest of lead counsel Gakwaya before and Peter Erlinder stand out among many. The Registrar Mr.AdamaDieng made appropriate representations to the UN and the states concerned that counsel appearing before the tribunal enjoyed functional immunity regarding the work they did relating to the defense of their clients appearing before the tribunal.The Appeals Chamber of the ICTR in the case of Peter Erlinder affirmed functional immunity and the privilege of counsel in the performance of his duties before the Tribunal and the privilege of all material relating to the case to which he was assigned. When the communication of  Charles Taylor  and his counsel were placed under surveillance and recorded at the ICC detention center at the Hague, upon appropriate representations made by  the Registrar of  the Special Court  to the President of the court,  the President made firm orders  forthe immediate removal of the surveillance camera from any conference room used for legal consultations” and that“All communication between lawyer and client shall be regarded as privileged” unless otherwise ordered by a judge or a Chamber”.

Institutional defense management mechanisms

The ICTR established a Defense Counsel Management Section (DCMS) headed by a Senior Legal Officer working under the direct supervision of the Registrar.  One enduring legacy of the ICTR is the establishment of the Lump sum system of payment of counsel professional fees after wide consultation with counsel and defense teams.   This did not alleviate the dire budgetary constraints to which the defense was subjected. However, consulting the defense on a crucial matter concerning their mandate was a significant and unprecedented act of recognition and respect. The SCSL Registrar in Rule 45 of its Rules of Procedure and Evidence established the Office of the Public Defender whose functions were to ensure an effective defense at earlier stages, assign counsel and offer assistance to counsel. The Principal Defender exercised relative independence in providing support to counsel and accused persons and standing in for counsel at trial sessions when counsel for some reason could not attend court.  The Office of the Public Defenderwas an improvement on the status of defense counsel.

Duties and obligations of the defense

Defense counsels are guided by ethical rules defined by the courts and tribunals. Defense counsels are officers of the court and thus, have duties towards their clients but also serve the proper administration of justice.  The Appeals Chamber of the ICTR decided in Prosecutor V. Jean Bosco Barayagwiza that defense counsels participate in international tribunals to defend their clients but also to ensure the fairness and integrity of trial proceedings and the interest of justice. Permit me in conclusion to state thatthe journey from Nuremberg to the Tribunal for Lebanon has been long and tedious, takingclose toseventy-five years. Nevertheless, the wisdom of the Security Council and the International Community in according institutional recognition to the defense in the Lebanon Tribunal as an independent organ of the court must be celebrated. Unfortunately this solution has not been followed by other courts; in particular theICC where theRegistrarwho was in Sierra Leone and Lebanon when the successes being celebrated were recorded who regrettably is proposing to a solution that significantly undermines the independence of the defense. Additionally, the enduring legacies established by the ICTR and the Special Court for Sierra Leone regarding the protection of defense counsel and privileged communications, the lump sum system of payment and the Witness Protection Mechanism seems also not to have been followed. Yet this legacy belongs not to these courts and tribunals but to humanity at large and posterity. A disappointing lack of institutional dialogue between the courts and tribunals seem to have inhibited the application of the Lebanon Tribunal solution to a critical institutional problem. There is no acceptable justification to struggle with this matter any longer when an acceptable solution has been provided by the Security Council applying the principles of justice and international law” in recognizing the equality,  independence, relevance and contributions of the defense to international criminal justice.

Chief Charles A. Taku is a Senior Contributing Editor of Cameroon Concord.

 

 

Share your views on this article

Email This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Sports

2018 world cup:
The indomitable Lions will not benefit from the sum of 8.4 billion Fcfa, which they would have been offered if they qualified for the upcoming
14 Nov 2017
Football-Russia 2018:
The final round of World Cup qualifying is taking place, and 27 countries are already assured of their places alongside hosts Russia at next summer's
13 Nov 2017
World cup qualifiers:
Cameroon's last match of the Russian world cup qualifiers against Zambia has ended in a draw. {loadposition myposition}   The lions found
11 Nov 2017
World cup qualifier
The Cameroonian professional who plays in Henan Jianye, China, will miss the lions’ encounter against Zambia on Saturday 11 November 2017.
09 Nov 2017
Anglophone clubs boated
The woes of Anglophones in Cameroon were further compounded over the weekend, when two of their soccer flag bearers in the 2017 Cup of Cameroon semi
07 Nov 2017
Football-Cameroon cup:
The two teams to play the final of the 57th edition of the Cameroon cup are known. New stars of Douala, shall meet with UMS of Loum in the final,
06 Nov 2017

Religion

A simple definition of justice is "fairness in the way people are treated." Justice is fundamental to the world. That is why in truly democratic
09 Oct 2017
All Church Services In
All church services in the North West and South West Regions of Cameroon have been moved from Sunday, October 1, 2017, to Sarturday, September 30,
25 Sep 2017
Bishop Benoit Balla:
Pascal Boade, who served in the Bafia Diocese as a technician and driver, is reported to have died mysteriously three months after the disappearance
14 Sep 2017
Bishop Benoit Balla:
A local private radio station, Radio Balafon based in the Litoral Region, reported an incident which occurred on Monday 28 August. It is about traces
29 Aug 2017
Anglophone Crisis May
 A renowned Pentecostal Man of God, Archbishop Godfred Anyere Tarh, has warned President Paul Biya and his cronies to hold inclusive dialogue with
28 Aug 2017
Cameroon: PCC moderator
To all the Presbyterial Secretaries          -Presbyterial Treasurers          -Pastors          -Principals          -Managers of Schools         
23 Aug 2017

Business / Economy

Canada-Cameroon
The High Commissioner of #Canada to #Cameroon, H.E. Richard Bale joined Mr. Henri Eyebe Ayissi, Minister of State Property, Surveys and Land Tenure
14 Aug 2020
Africa Food Manufacture
(Business in Cameroon) - On July 30, 2020, Africa Food Manufacture (AFM), which produces Broli-branded pasta, signed an investment agreement with
09 Aug 2020
Cameroonian insurance
(Business in Cameroon) - Cameroonian insurance company Chanas Assurances, majority-owned by National Hydrocaborns company SNH, informs that it
09 Aug 2020
Cameroon receives FCFA
The European Union has reportedly reached a two-year deal with Cameroon. The EU will grant Cameroon about FCFA 63 billion. {loadposition
11 Nov 2017
Vodafone calls off
In a press release made public today, the telecom company states that it is no longer commercially viable to resume activities in Cameroon. It
10 Nov 2017
Cameroon: 'Gold
There are unconfirmed reports that say gold has been discovered in a  locality called Song Matip near Eseka in the Centre region.Eseka is that famous
04 Nov 2017

Daily / Newsbrief

Civil war meets
Just as it is our moral duty to join the global collaborative efforts to eradicate COVID-19, it is also our moral duty to ensure our fellow human
14 Aug 2020
Cameroun soldiers shot
Soldiers loyal to LR's dictator, Mr. Biya just shot at a boat driver in Nsanakang village in Eyumojock Sub-division, Manyu Division. National
14 Nov 2017
Anglophone crisis: One
At least one civilian has reportedly died in Muyuka in the South West region  following violent confrontations with forces of La Republique.The
13 Nov 2017
Cameroon: Presidential
A man named Akono Christian, has poured boiled water on her girlfriend, who went to visit him. {loadposition myposition}   Unfortunate Tchana
11 Nov 2017
Cameroon:Detained for
Accused of involvement in the murder of the son of Rear Admiral Joseph Fouda(special adviser of President Paul Biya), Michael Feumba claims innocence
10 Nov 2017
Lady shot dead in
A young lady who was injured in an attack in the North West region of Cameroon on Tuesday night breaking Wednesday has finally passed on.Janet
09 Nov 2017

Entertainment

P Square breaks up
Reports going round suggest Nigerian duo P Square have split up after a misunderstanding . Peter and Paul Okoye, twin brothers, have reportedly gone
27 September 2017
Coming Soon: Rigobert
Reports say a documentary on the life of the former captain of the Indomitable Lions of Cameroon will be presented at the Ecrans noirs film festival
15 July 2017
False news: Don Moen
The American gospel singer has tweeted after he was reported to be dead by a certain website, HoustonChronicle-TV.com on Wednesday 12 July 2017.
13 July 2017
Douala: SDO bans Maahlox
The SDO for Douala 5, Tchakui Nounde Jean Marie, has signed a release banning the controversial Cameroonian musician, Maahlox le vibeur from holding
01 July 2017
Yaounde: Malhox
Cameroonian rapper Mahlox, who is popularly known for his song "ça sort comme ça sort", was reportedly agressed yestersay June 17. He had gone to
18 June 2017
Cameroonian musician
A young Cameroonian singer is currently under intensive medical care in Yaoundé after narrowly escaping death in a rather shocking car accident.
10 June 2017

Cameroon Concord  is an online publication covering and reporting on  local and world news, sports, entertainment, politics, business, and religious news. Serving Cameroonians .

Newsletter

 

Get the latest news and information delivered directly to your inbox by subscribing to our news alerts.

ADVERTISE

X

Right Click

No right click

We use cookies to improve our website. By continuing to use this website, you are giving consent to cookies being used. More details…